If you've ever walked through Downtown Arlington Heights on a Friday night, you know exactly what I'm talking about – the intoxicating smell of wood-fired pizza mixed with the sizzle of fajitas, the warm glow spilling out of the restaurants, and the happy hum of people enjoying their meals.
If you've ever walked through Downtown Arlington Heights on a Friday night, you know exactly what I'm talking about – the intoxicating smell of wood-fired pizza mixed with the sizzle of fajitas, the warm glow spilling out of the restaurants, and the happy hum of people enjoying their meals. This Chicago suburb has become one of the hottest dining destinations in the northwest suburbs.
What makes Downtown Arlington Heights special isn't the variety, though you can find everything from steakhouses to Irish pubs within a few blocks. It's the passion behind each restaurant where chefs aren't just cooking food, they're telling stories through their dishes. Whether you're looking for a romantic anniversary dinner or a spot to catch up with old friends, this walkable downtown has something that'll make your taste buds happy.
1. Passero
When I first walked into Passero last spring, I was immediately transported to a modern Italian trattoria. This isn't your typical red-sauce joint – Chef Ivan Jacobo has created something truly special here, blending traditional Italian-American recipes with seasonal ingredients and contemporary techniques. Moreover, the menu changes with the seasons, which means every visit feels like a new adventure.
Signature Dishes
The homemade gnocchi here is pure magic – pillowy soft potato dumplings that practically melt on your tongue. Additionally, I still dream about the ricotta-stuffed ravioli I had last month, swimming in a sage brown butter sauce that had me literally scraping the plate clean.
And don't even get me started on their wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas. The leopard-spotted crust has that perfect char, with just the right amount of chew.
Atmosphere & Experience
Passero strikes that elusive balance between cozy and contemporary. The exposed brick walls and warm lighting create an intimate atmosphere that's perfect for date night, but the energy is lively enough that you won't feel out of place bringing the whole family.
Last time I was there, I watched a couple get engaged at the corner table while a family celebrated their son's graduation just two tables over – that's the beauty of this place.
2. Mago Grill & Cantina
Mago isn't just another Mexican restaurant – it's a culinary journey through Aztec-inspired cuisine with creative twists that'll challenge everything you thought you knew about Mexican food. Furthermore, the tequila menu alone deserves its own paragraph, featuring over 100 varieties that the knowledgeable staff will happily guide you through.
Signature Dishes
The restaurant's standout dishes include:
- The skirt steak enchiladas are legendary around here, tender and flavorful with a mole sauce that has layers of complexity
- Their shrimp empanadas arrive at your table golden and crispy, filled with succulent shrimp and cheese
- But if you're feeling adventurous, try the roasted grasshopper guacamole – yes, you read that right. It's surprisingly delicious and adds a unique crunch that'll have you questioning why this isn't more common
Location & Vibes
Situated right in the heart of downtown, Mago's vibrant, colorful interior mirrors the bold flavors on the plate. The hand-painted murals and festive atmosphere make every meal feel like a celebration.
Plus, the downtown location means you can easily walk off that third margarita with a stroll through the neighborhood.
3. altThai
Don't let the lowercase styling fool you – altThai makes a bold statement with its traditional Thai cuisine infused with Pan-Asian influences. This place has become my go-to when I'm craving something with serious spice and complex flavors that dance on my palate.
Recommended Dishes
Must-try menu items at altThai:
- The spicy duck rolls are an absolute must-try – crispy on the outside with tender, flavorful duck inside, served with a tangy dipping sauce
- Their shrimp pineapple curry perfectly balances sweet and spicy
- The crispy tilapia salad offers a refreshing contrast with its bright, zesty dressing and satisfying crunch
Why It Stands Out
What I love about altThai is how it maintains authenticity while remaining approachable. The relaxed setting doesn't feel intimidating if you're new to Thai cuisine, and the staff is always happy to adjust spice levels.
Being just steps from the Metra station makes it perfect for commuters looking for a quick but satisfying dinner before heading home.
4. Peggy Kinnane's Irish Restaurant & Pub
Peggy Kinnane's is where authentic Irish hospitality meets American comfort. This isn't just a restaurant; it's a gathering place where strangers become friends over pints of Guinness and hearty meals. The multi-generational crowds on weekends tell you everything you need to know about this beloved institution.
Highlighted Menu Items
The menu features creative takes on classic pub fare:
- The Reuben egg rolls are genius – all the flavors of a classic Reuben wrapped in a crispy shell and served with thousand island dipping sauce
- Their Wisconsin beer cheese soup is like a warm hug in a bowl, especially on those brutal Chicago winter days
- And the Guinness-infused cheddar sliders? They're the perfect bar food elevated to an art form
Atmosphere & Entertainment
With live music most nights and a spacious outdoor patio that's packed from May through October, Peggy's offers more than just a meal – it's an experience. The authentic Irish pub atmosphere, complete with dark wood and vintage signs, makes you feel like you've been transported to Dublin.
5. Palm Court
When you want to impress someone – really impress them – Palm Court is where you go. This elegant fine-dining steakhouse features three distinct dining rooms and a sophisticated cocktail lounge. The white tablecloths and attentive service harken back to a golden age of dining when going out for dinner was an event.
Star Dishes
The filet mignon here is perfection – butter-tender and cooked precisely to your specifications. Pair it with a lobster tail for the ultimate surf and turf experience.
But save room for dessert, because their tableside flambé show is not to be missed. Watching your server prepare bananas foster or cherries jubilee right at your table adds theater to an already memorable meal.
Added Appeal
Weekend live entertainment in the lounge adds another dimension to the dining experience. Whether it's jazz on Friday nights or piano standards on Saturday, the music enhances without overwhelming conversation.
Honorable Mentions
While these five restaurants represent the cream of the crop, Downtown Arlington Heights has even more to offer:
- Parea Greek Kitchen brings authentic Mediterranean flavors with their exceptional lamb dishes and fresh seafood
- The Prospect impresses with its modern American menu and craft cocktail program that rivals anything you'll find in the city
- And The Foxtail, with its eclectic ambiance and elevated comfort food, has quickly become a local favorite since opening
Dining Tips in Downtown Arlington Heights
Timing is everything when dining downtown. During Arlington Alfresco (held on select summer weekends), the streets come alive with outdoor dining and live entertainment, but reservations become essential. Weeknight dining tends to be more relaxed, perfect for trying that restaurant you've been eyeing without the weekend crowds.
Essential tips for the best dining experience:
- Always make reservations for Friday and Saturday nights, especially at Passero and Palm Court
- Most restaurants here are within walking distance of each other, so consider making an evening of it – cocktails at one spot, dinner at another, and maybe dessert at a third
Our Final Thoughts
Downtown Arlington Heights has evolved into a true culinary destination that rivals many big-city dining scenes. From Passero's refined Italian to Peggy Kinnane's hearty Irish fare, these five restaurants showcase the incredible diversity and quality that make this suburb a must-visit for food lovers. Each offers its own unique experience while maintaining the high standards that have put Arlington Heights on the culinary map.
So what are you waiting for? Pick a restaurant, make a reservation, and prepare for a dining experience that'll have you planning your next visit before you've even finished your meal. Your taste buds will thank you, and you'll understand why locals can't stop raving about their downtown dining scene. See you at the table!